Philly Cheese Steak Shoppe - Arcata, CA
A bit pricey but you can pay with HSU c-points which is great for students on a meal plan who are tired of the food on campus. I recommend the mushroom pepper steak and the jalepeno ranch steak.
Such great ambiance and pretty good prices. They have great tea, which is something I really value as a non-coffee drinker! Not just for bagles - love the peanut butter chocolate chip cookies!